Best Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cookies Recipe

The butterfinger peanut butter cookies recipe has become a favorite among home bakers who crave something both nostalgic and indulgent. It combines creamy peanut butter with crunchy Butterfinger candy pieces to create a cookie that feels both classic and exciting. Because peanut butter cookies are already loved worldwide, adding Butterfinger transforms them into a bakery-style treat that stands out.

This recipe is written in a clear, easy-to-follow third-person style, allowing anyone to recreate it. Moreover, it uses simple pantry staples, making it practical for everyday baking. Whether preparing dessert for guests or baking a family treat, this recipe consistently delivers flavorful results.

In addition, it strikes the perfect balance between soft centers and crispy edges. Thanks to the caramelized candy pieces, each bite offers texture and richness. So, let’s explore what makes this cookie recipe truly unforgettable.

Why This Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cookies Recipe Stands Out

Flavor Profile and Texture

These butterfinger peanut butter cookies deliver layers of flavor. First, there’s the nutty depth of peanut butter. Then comes the buttery sweetness from brown sugar. Finally, the crushed Butterfinger pieces add crunch and caramel notes.

The cookies bake with golden edges and soft centers. Because of the candy bits, every bite feels dynamic. Additionally, the slight saltiness from peanut butter enhances the sweetness without overpowering it.

Who Will Love This Recipe

• Peanut butter lovers
• Candy enthusiasts
• Beginner bakers
• Families baking together
• Holiday dessert planners

In short, it’s a crowd-pleaser. Even those who aren’t big fans of peanut butter often appreciate the candy crunch twist.

Ingredients Breakdown and Smart Substitutions

Core Ingredients

• 1 cup creamy peanut butter
• ½ cup unsalted butter
• 1 cup brown sugar
• ½ cup granulated sugar
• 2 large eggs
• 2 cups all-purpose flour
• 1 tsp baking soda
• ½ tsp salt
• 1 cup crushed Butterfinger candy bars

Each ingredient plays a critical role. For example, brown sugar adds moisture, while baking soda ensures proper rise.

Optional Add-Ins

• Chocolate chips
• Sea salt flakes
• Chopped peanuts
• Mini marshmallows

If someone prefers a slightly healthier option, natural peanut butter can be used, though it may alter texture slightly.

Step-by-Step Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cookies Recipe

Preparation Stage

1. Preheat oven to 350°F (175°C).
2. Line baking trays with parchment paper.
3. Crush Butterfinger bars into small chunks.

Preparation ensures smooth baking. Moreover, pre-measuring ingredients prevents mistakes.

Mixing the Dough

1. Cream butter and sugars until fluffy.
2. Add peanut butter and mix thoroughly.
3. Beat in eggs one at a time.
4. In a separate bowl, combine flour, baking soda, and salt.
5. Gradually fold dry ingredients into wet mixture.
6. Stir in crushed Butterfinger pieces.

The dough should be soft but not sticky.

Baking and Cooling

1. Scoop dough into 1.5-inch balls.
2. Place 2 inches apart on tray.
3. Bake for 10–12 minutes.
4. Cool on tray for 5 minutes before transferring.

Cookies will firm up as they cool.

Baking Science Behind Perfect Cookies

Understanding baking science improves results dramatically. For instance, creaming butter and sugar introduces air pockets, helping cookies rise properly. Furthermore, brown sugar contains molasses, which adds moisture and chewiness.

Peanut butter contributes fat and protein. Consequently, it influences spread and texture. Too much flour can result in dryness, while too little may cause excessive spreading.

Temperature matters as well. If dough is chilled for 20–30 minutes, cookies maintain thicker centers. Meanwhile, room-temperature dough spreads more.

By grasping these principles, bakers gain better control over texture and taste.

Expert Tips for Soft and Chewy Results

• Use room-temperature ingredients.
• Avoid overmixing after adding flour.
• Slightly underbake for softer centers.
• Add extra Butterfinger chunks on top before baking.
• Let cookies rest on baking sheet briefly.

Additionally, using parchment paper prevents burning and ensures even baking.

Storage, Freezing, and Make-Ahead Tips

Cookies stay fresh in an airtight container for up to 5 days. For longer storage:

• Freeze baked cookies up to 3 months.
• Freeze raw dough balls individually.
• Thaw overnight before baking.

This flexibility makes the butterfinger peanut butter cookies recipe ideal for busy households.

Nutritional Overview

Nutrient	Approximate Value (Per Cookie)
Calories	180
Fat	10g
Carbs	20g
Protein	4g
Sugar	12g

Moderation is key. However, homemade cookies allow better ingredient control compared to store-bought alternatives.

Creative Variations to Try

• Add melted chocolate drizzle
• Create cookie sandwiches with frosting
• Use crunchy peanut butter
• Replace Butterfinger with other candy bars

Experimentation keeps baking fun and personalized.

Serving Suggestions and Pairings

These cookies pair wonderfully with:

• Cold milk
• Hot coffee
• Vanilla ice cream
• Dessert platters

They’re especially popular during holidays and celebrations.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

1. Overbaking leads to dry cookies.
2. Skipping parchment causes sticking.
3. Incorrect flour measurement changes the texture.
4. Using stale candy reduces crunch.

Careful attention ensures success every time.

FAQs About Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cookies

1. Can the dough be chilled overnight?

Yes, the dough can be chilled overnight, and it often improves the flavor and texture. Chilling allows the flour to fully hydrate and the fats to solidify, which helps control spreading during baking. As a result, the cookies bake thicker with a chewier center and richer taste. Just cover the dough tightly and let it sit at room temperature for 10–15 minutes before scooping.

2. Can crunchy peanut butter be used instead of creamy?

Crunchy peanut butter works very well in this recipe. It adds extra texture and enhances the nutty flavor in every bite. However, the cookies may spread slightly differently depending on the brand used. For best results, use a well-stirred, stable peanut butter rather than one that separates too much, as excess oil can affect consistency.

3. Are these cookies freezer-friendly?

Yes, these cookies freeze beautifully. Baked cookies can be stored in an airtight container in the freezer for up to three months. Dough balls can also be frozen individually and baked directly from frozen, adding an extra 1–2 minutes to the baking time. This makes the recipe perfect for meal prep or holiday planning.

4. Can gluten-free flour be substituted?

A 1:1 gluten-free baking flour blend can be used successfully in this recipe. Make sure the blend contains xanthan gum or a binding agent to maintain structure. The texture may be slightly softer, but the flavor remains delicious. Always measure carefully and avoid overmixing to prevent dense results.

5. How long do the cookies stay fresh?

When stored in an airtight container at room temperature, the cookies remain fresh for up to five days. To maintain softness, placing a small slice of bread in the container can help retain moisture. For longer storage, freezing is recommended. Proper storage ensures the cookies stay chewy and flavorful.

6. Can other candies replace Butterfinger?

Yes, other candy bars can be substituted if desired. Options like chocolate-covered toffee or peanut-based candies work especially well. Keep in mind that sweetness and texture may change depending on the candy used. Choose candies that hold their structure during baking to maintain a satisfying crunch.

Conclusion

This butterfinger peanut butter cookies recipe delivers a perfect balance of sweetness, crunch, and rich peanut flavor. With simple ingredients and flexible variations, it suits both beginners and experienced bakers. By following proper baking techniques and storage tips, consistent results are easy to achieve. For additional baking guidance and expert resources, visit King Arthur Baking at https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/learn.

Print